In 1990 John Entwistle spent two months in the region of Connemara on the west coast of Ireland where fierce winds coming off the Atlantic soon blew away any traces of last night’s old red wine. Here, in a stone house that was once the home of an archbishop, he began to write his life story, in longhand on A4 lined paper. He never finished the task and it remained unpublished during his lifetime but the tenor of what he wrote, in equal measure amusing, cynical and bitter, hangs over this biography like a dark thundercloud.
         For all his wealth, acclaim and success John Entwistle was not a contented man. His dissatisfaction stemmed from issues he never felt able to enunciate, and it saw him retreat into himself, chasing his demons in ways that did him no good at all: booze, drugs, women, bad diets, reckless shopping sprees and an obstinacy that translated into denial. Many interviewees for this book – and they include both his ex-wives and son, as well as many musician friends – all seemed incapable of confronting him about these matters simply because, in his dealings with and without The Who, his natural instinct was always to avoid confrontations.
         All of this contributes to a deep, persistent melancholia in the life of John Entwistle as conveyed by former Q editor Paul Rees. Less conspicuous than his colleagues in The Who but no less fascinating, Entwistle remained a distant, reserved figure to many, a character trait reinforced by the high profile antics of Pete Townshend, Roger Daltrey and Keith Moon. In this way, his story echoes what might be termed ‘The Bassists’ Curse’ – to be undervalued, unfulfilled and frustrated – and along with much else this led indirectly to his death at the relatively young age of 57.
         While the The Who itself and the other three members have inspired books aplenty, Entwistle has until now lagged behind. The dilemma facing biographers of individual group members is in separating their subject from the group, and, with Entwistle’s peculiar nature only aggravating the situation, it is no surprise that the book suggests there were two Johns – John of The Who, and John of The Home. The former is the well-known Ox with the spider emblem around his neck, dapper, on the left of the stage, motionless save for fingers a blur on the long necks of his various basses, a rock star who dives eagerly into all the temptations that his calling offers him. The latter, however, is seemingly hewn from the same oak as The Kinks’ ‘Well Respected Man’. Off stage John Entwistle invariably behaves like an old-fashioned gentleman, well turned out, well spoken, and well mannered, a well-to-do professional man who lives his life by routines and loves a plate of fish and chips. The rot sets in when the two Johns start to merge. 
         The 344-page book is divided into three parts, the first about John’s early years, the second about The Who and his role within it, and the third his sad, ultimately tragic decline as Townshend and/or Daltrey put The Who on hold, leaving their brilliant bass guitarist to drift aimlessly. It came about after Rees wrote a profile of Entwistle for Classic Rock magazine for which he interviewed Alison, John’s childhood sweetheart and first wife, and Christopher, their son. The acquaintance made, Alison and Christopher co-operated with Rees when he proposed a full scale biography, and it is clear from its pages that their testimony, along with that of Maxene Harlow, John’s American second wife, was crucial to his research. Alison and Christopher also handed over John’s own text, enabling him to quote from it at will, and this helps the book enormously.
         The result is very readable, leaning more towards the fate of the overindulged, hedonistic rock star and his troubled life than the music he created. Those looking for an insight into Entwistle’s extraordinary bass technique will be disappointed; although Rees heaps plenty of praise on John’s unique skills, he hasn’t spoken to other bass players about how John did what he did. A handful of musicians express their admiration for John’s work too, but there is no attempt to analyse it, Rees having evidently concluded that to do so would decelerate the book’s pace.
         John Entwistle’s early life was far from comfortable. An only child, he was 18 months old when his parents separated. He took an instant, everlasting dislike to his mother’s next partner and money was tight, which might explain why when he became rich he insisted on a preposterously high standard of living that would forever strain his finances. A naturally gifted musician, he inherited his talents from his parents and took lessons on the piano, then brass instruments and finally taught himself to play bass guitar because he liked the sound of Duane Eddy’s records. He took pleasure in making his first bass and thereafter immersed himself in the instrument, its makes, models and modes of amplification. His introduction to Townshend and, later, Daltrey, more or less tallies with all the other Who books I have, and The Who’s story is told – yet again (!) – in a breezy, competent fashion that differs from the rest only in that it benefits from John’s wry observations recorded in the text he wrote himself.
         It is no secret that they didn’t get on personally, and Rees spares no blushes in detailing the various fall outs. Daltrey doesn’t come out of it well, a bit of a grumpy old bugger; Townshend is usually in a world of his own, a surprisingly absent presence in the book; and Moon is as mad as a box of frogs, though it is the drummer with whom Entwistle bonds most easily, the pair sharing a love of practical jokes and disorderly behaviour. The impression is given that Entwistle often provoked Moon in this and that he felt it was his duty to protect him, as if Keith was the little brother John never had. Moon’s death clearly affected Entwistle more than he let on. “I saw vulnerability in John when Keith died,” says manager Bill Curbishley. “There was something taken away from him that couldn’t ever be put back.”
         A recurring theme up to this point is The Who’s precarious finances which didn’t stabilise until Tommy was a success. When real money arrived at last, all bar Daltrey were reckless spenders and Entwistle maintained his profligate ways until the very end, stockpiling possessions galore that filled his houses to the brim, even Quarwood, near Stow On The Wold in Gloucestershire, the gigantic pile he bought in 1976 and owned until his death. Rees contends that John’s collection of bass guitars was the biggest in the world.
         The crux for Entwistle came when Townshend brought the curtain down on The Who for the first time at the end of 1982. ‘To Entwistle, Townshend’s decision was a personal affront,’ writes Rees. ‘Initially, he was despairing, but soon enough this turned to a seething, burning resentment.’ “He would have toured and toured,” adds Curbishley. “That was his life.”
         Already dark, Entwistle’s life from this point onwards becomes a calamity of almost epic proportions. Outwardly buoyant but inwardly furious, he increases his consumption of all the poisons, chief among them brandy and cocaine, he’d happily ingested in The Who, confident that his physical strength can withstand it all. For a long time, far longer than Moon, this was the case but as we move from the eighties into the nineties it becomes clear that the only difference between Entwistle and Moon was that it took him an extra 24 years to kill himself.
            Serially promiscuous, John divorces Alison – who is heartbroken – and takes up with Maxene, a nice LA girl who before long realises that keeping up with John will kill her and joins AA, only for this to put a wedge between them. She is followed by Lisa, a bad LA girl, who matches John glass for glass and toke for toke and who is ultimately blamed, at least by Christopher, for killing his father. “It was Lisa that truly fucked him up,” he says. “And I hate her for what she did to him.”
         John’s tours with his own bands are covered extensively – as, throughout, are his solo recordings – but there is a nagging sense that he’s flogging a dead horse. The only respite from this descent into hell – as the red tops would have it – are those occasions when Townshend and Daltrey elect to reform The Who for various reasons, not least among them to shore up their finances. But no sooner is Entwistle back in the black than he’s on the phone to Harrods, his preferred retailer.
         Entwistle played his last show with The Who at London’s Royal Albert Hall on February 8, 2002, but it was comforting to be reminded that the last show he played with them in America – a country he loved – was in October 2001 at Madison Square Garden, the Concert For New York to recognise the firemen who died in 9/11, and that it was a triumph, one of the group’s best ever in the post-Moon era.
         As is well known, John Entwistle died on June 27, 2002, in Las Vegas from a heart attack induced not by the previous night’s consumption but by a lifetime of indulgence. There was a bit of unpleasantness in the aftermath, much of it caused by Lisa, but in a poignant Epilogue we join Alison and Christopher at a garden party in 2018, the pair of them sharing memories with old Who retainers of the man they remember as husband and father. “He was a very silly boy, but I loved him for years and years, and I didn’t stop loving him,” says the girl who knew him long before he was John of The Who. She preferred John of The Home and was, after all, just 13 when that 14-year-old boy began courting her.  
         Finally, the book is well indexed, lacks a discography and I’m not too keen on the cover which looks a bit washed out to me. The cover of the US edition, below, is far better.



Alan McKendree said...

Great review, Chris. It'll give me a bit of a melancholy mindset before I start on my copy.

"The Last of the Great Rock Stars" always seemed a little odd to me as John's summarizing epithet. Much as I revered John, I'm not sure it applies.

I agree about the UK cover -- seems like he deserved better (as on the US cover). Maybe there's a story behind that photo to recommend it.

Keyboard Worrier said...

Yes, this is a very good review. It's the sort that makes you want to go and buy the book.

Anonymous said...

Can't be anymore melancholy than Annette Walter laxs "The last Four Years",a depressing read,made even more so by a $30 price tag.

Keith P. said...

"...the well-known Ox with the spider emblem around his neck, stage left, motionless..."

Ox was always stage right, Pete stage left. "Stage ____" refers to the point of view from the stage looking out at the audience. Can't wait to read this book! Didn't know it was coming out.

John Medd said...

It'll be on my list - thanks.

Chris Charlesworth said...

My mistake, now corrected. Thank you. CC

wardo said...

Looking forward to it, thanks for the details!

Paul the ex Bassman said...

Sounds a sad tale.. at the moment my inclination is to avoid.. I’ll keep my bass hero in my mind as I remember him.

Why When How Who said...

Hi Chris as always , a great and thoughtful review. I like that you as great journalist do, don’t hold back on your opinion of various players that blessed Entwistle’ Life even though you are a massive fan , . I’ve only read recent Daltrey bio which I thought lacked detail and Townshend’s Who am I which Probably was too honest and I admit I was confronted by Townshend. His god like status was harmed and in my eyes. All good now!
And I will catch up on Moon’s bio. But Entwistle was an enigma . His fellow band members thrashed out themselves on stage but John still kept himself a gentleman and able to remain stoic whilst those around seemingly crazy! Off stage was his time to enjoy his inner child .

Neil Storey said...

Fair comment all through – its a really good read, lucky enough to have a preview copy and it is a genuine page turner. A pity that Townshend and Daltrey didn't cooperate – can but assume that since neither are direct quoted. Find that a little disrespectful since (just my view) The 'oo were always a sum of their parts.

MEB said...

Great review thanks, Chris. It just seems so tragic that someone with such awesome talent and who gave so much pleasure to others wasn't able to really benefit from his own success.

Unknown said...

"His introduction to Townshend and, later, Daltrey"

He met Daltrey first.
He introduced Townshend to Daltrey.

Great write up, I never thought I would be inclined to read a JAE bio.

Unknown said...

Wait, you're correct...
He did know PT first.
But he did introduce Townshend to Daltrey.
If anyone cares.

Chris Charlesworth said...

Yes, Pete and John were in a band together before John hooked up with Rodger and suggested Pete joined too.

wardo said...

Got my copy the other day, and read it immediately. Some good stories, plus excellent perspective on stories we've heard. My biggest beef is the misspelling of critic John Mendelsohn and producer Bill Szymczyk's names. Plus, pretty sure John wore the skeleton suit at the 1970 Isle of Wight, not 1969.

Unknown said...

Enjoyed the book but I have to point out the errors on pages 272 and 273. My hometown area is called Glens Falls, NY, not Glen Falls and not Glen Springs as referred to only 1 page later. Hope it can be fixed in time for the 2nd printing.

Chris Charlesworth said...

You are right, and I pointed that (skeleton suit) out to the author in private e-mail.

Anonymous said...

You got something wrong thar is going to cost you. I was NEVER a good time girl. I knew John for 13 years. And many other rockers. I have proven legally that I never was a hooker either. What an asshole you are. Just slapdash in you research and opinion...and for what?? The sensationalism? You are rather washed down and dull not to mention a steeple who is too lazy to research a subject. Your credibility is ridiculous at best. Remove the offensive words immediately and you won't have to pay my lawyer like Roger Dalteey, and others have. Asshole. You know the truth because I've reached out several times yet you intentionally ignore me for the tiny bit of stupid adoration? Oh bless your ignorant heart. Big mistake.
Alycen Rowse